Comments

I've seen this error before, but I'm not exactly sure what it is other than that something is apparently missing for them to display properly.
I believe, Jak, these are the characters Firefox supposedly shows for certain undefined characters, but that it doesn’t recognize that the fonts concerned actually have them there. There have always been some major issues with Firefox typography, and while many of the serious ones have been ironed out, it looks like this one hasn’t.
Well, that would explain a lot.

Re: your other link/blog post:

I am a regular Joe who wants the products simply to work.


That actually is a common refrain that I have heard many, many, many times in Linux forums from Windows emigrates or part-time users. Unfortunately, Linux is a bit hobbled by its hobbyist roots, and established Linux devotees can be quite rude to neophytes (Gentoo users being the most commonly illustrated example). Many of the same are also stridently against standardization

I'm not sure what's up with Firefox-- I went to look see for myself. I have the same problem with FF 3.0.11 for Ubuntu. But the problem is consistent with Chromium (Google Chrome as it exists in open source), too. I have yet to check with Opera. Therefore, so far, it would seem to be a problem that has been perpetuated across various layout engines (Gecko for Firefox and Epiphany, WebKit for Chromium).
Jak, I think you are right. It must be the engines, and ironically, IE is the one that renders many of these characters correctly. (I have not used it on this particular page, but when I went from IE7 to Firefox 3, I noticed these boxed characters with the hexadecimal codes appearing everywhere.)
Being a font guy, I am often concerned about the compatibility of a lot of our fonts. That would be the number-one reason to not adopt Linux on my part, especially having licensed thousands of PostScript fonts over the last 20-odd years.
I'd think the open source community should be embarassed, then. In most every other respect, Internet Explorer gives web designers massive headaches with its proprietary HTML tags and coding. Touché, Jack; while I suppose it's not a very compelling counter argument, IE is far from perfect, and I know you have commented on this lack of compatibility.

Have you yet checked Opera?
[這個好]
As you may have read, Jak, I had sent information to the Mozilla people about the Firefox typographic problems (the failure for the Gecko engine to render even quotation marks in the correct font) and this remained faulty for versions 1 and 2. Version 3 is far superior, fixing some of these, and introduced recognition of kerning pairs (the space adjustment between two characters). So I agree, the open source community should have accepted and remedied some of these faults, especially when they were so glaring. But it took three years.
I was a huge supporter of the original Netscape browser, right up to version 4·7. It was only out of necessity I switched to IE5, which at that time was a fairly good browser, and the best for typography. (Netscape stopped recognizing PostScript typefaces, then still current, with version 6, at least on Windows.)
I also agree that Internet Explorer is an inferior browser in many respects, from standards to its sheer size. Even on a brisk Vista machine which I now have, it’s a clunker. It’s many, many times worse on the two XP machines in this particular office.
I haven’t checked Opera yet. I have checked out Chrome (downloaded within the first 24 hours!), Maxthon (IE engine, but its own skins, and much faster than IE, but slower than Firefox or Chrome), and, of course, Firefox. I have found quite a few errors with Firefox, sadly, especially with Wordpress, but they seem to have disappeared with the latest (2·8) incarnation.
Just checked now with Opera-- doesn't appear much better.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

Jack Yan

About Me

Jack Yan
New Zealand
‘I think they’re wonderful. They have so much courage! Here they are, hurling through space on a molten rock at 67,000 miles an hour, and the only thing that keeps them in their shoes is their misplaced faith in gravity.’—John Lithgow as Prof Dick Solomon, in Third Rock from the Sun
Bebo:
LucirePublisher
del.icio.us:
jackyan
Digg:
jackyan
Flickr:
lucire
MySpace:
jackyan
Other:
http://www.facebook.com/jack.yan
Technorati:
jackyan
Twitter:
jackyan
YouTube:
luciremagazine

My Groups

Neighborhood

Explore friends, family, friends & family, or entire neighborhood.

Archives

  • Powered by Vox

Magazines